• About

Citiography

~ Cities: How They Work, or Don't

Citiography

Category Archives: big picture

Our Pollution Footprint and Job Creation

06 Tuesday Sep 2011

Posted by Kelly Bennett in big picture, geography, globalization, Jobs, pollution

≈ Leave a comment

It shouldn’t surprise anyone that Apple, an American Company, made my iPhone in China (mostly). I find it disappointing, though, that Apple’s suppliers were just accused for a second time of polluting several communities there. Then, a couple days ago, I was disappointed again when President Obama abandoned a more restrictive air pollution rule that was recommended by the EPA. The reason for doing this was, of course, jobs.

The argument usually goes that environmental protections are job killers. Where I live, in the Piedmont of North Carolina, air quality has gotten much better over the last 15 years. It’s not because of pollution controls, though. It has more to do with the tens of thousands of manufacturing jobs that disappeared from the region. Until recently, this area used to be the American center of textile and furniture manufacturing. People here wax poetic about how the local rivers would run whatever color the mills happened to be dyeing that day. It’s not that way anymore. The mills are largely closed, the rivers are mostly clear, and the air is more breathable. And a lot of people are out of work. So, if it wasn’t pollution controls that put these people out of work, what was it? NAFTA. I’m sure it’s cheaper to dump pollutants into the nearest river, but what’s driving manufacturing jobs oversees has more to do with wages, currency markets and trade agreements than pollution regulations.

Still, some people think we should open ourselves up to a bit more pollution to provide a kind of lesser-evil alternative to the uber-pollution status quo in China. It’s a decent argument, and I’m open to the possibility that some regulations may go too far, but I doubt a significant number of jobs would come back to the US if we start down this path. It begs the question though — what’s our responsibility for pollution in other countries? The world?

Pollution rules are built into many international treaties and regulations; maybe we need to concentrate our attention there instead. After all, if trade agreements are driving pollution, maybe trade agreements can tamp it down. Of course, the elephant in the room is carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. Should we start there? A cap and trade system has the potential to stop manufacturing firms from chasing the lowest wage and start chasing the cleanest facility. That sounds like a situation that could create jobs here.

Advertisement

Image

What kind of city do you deserve?

20 Saturday Aug 2011

Geography is everywhere, especially in our cities. It’s why the Rust Belt used to be shiny (the Erie Canal) and why my beautiful bungalow was so damn cheap (the schools suck). It’s also the reason you probably drive everywhere even though gas is so expensive (we’ve built our cities in a way that you don’t often have a choice).

Geography answers the question, why there? It’s a useful thing to know if your job is to steer an entity of hundreds of thousands (millions?) of people, making individual decisions. “Steer” is too strong a word, though. Educated and influence those who steer my city is more like it.

You see, city planning is ultimately a democratic process. Every decision is voted on by your city council, whose members want to keep their residents happy. If city residents, aka voters, don’t understand how a city works, they can’t be expected to support the difficult decisions their elected officials need to make.

And that’s what I want to do here, just on a bigger scale. I’m a city planner who wants his city to work for all the people who live here. A city should give its residents access — access to jobs, education, community, a safe place to live, good health, and a way to participate. But this blog isn’t so much about my city; it’s about our cities. When you add it all up, we’re talking about big-picture stuff — the environment, the economy, our futures. So, if more of us understand how our cities work, maybe we’ll get the cities we deserve.

Posted by Kelly Bennett | Filed under big picture, cities, geography

≈ 2 Comments

Archives

  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • November 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011

Categories

  • big picture
  • casinos
  • cities
  • decline
  • Detroit
  • economics
  • farms
  • gambling
  • geography
  • globalization
  • historic preservation
  • Housing
  • incremental change
  • Jobs
  • local food
  • Mobility
  • New York City
  • oil sands
  • parking lots
  • Photos
  • pollution
  • Renewable Energy
  • ruins
  • schools
  • sprawl
  • streetcars
  • tar sands
  • taxes
  • transit
  • transportation
  • urban planning

Facebook

Facebook

Twitter

  • RT @krassenstein: May 15th, 2018 is the #SinclairStrike. 1) Sinclair Broadcasting Employees call out sick 2) Sinclair viewers boycott the… 4 years ago
  • RT @justkelly_ok: Where are the indictments of individuals at USA Gymnastics and MSU who enabled and covered up this abuse for decades, as… 5 years ago
Follow @Citiography

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Citiography
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Citiography
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...